A more accurate accurate method to estimate glomerular filtration rate from serum creatinine. The modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study was the largest randomized clinical trial to test the hypothesis that protein restriction slows the progression of chronic renal disease. Pharmacokinetics in patients with impaired renal function fda. A third formula, the ckdepi chronic kidney disease epidemiology collaboration equation, is based on the same four variables as the mdrd study formula but uses a 2slope spline to model. Modification of the modification of diet in renal disease. Previous studies that compared the mdrd study equation with the ckdepi equation in korea targeted patients with. Comparing the association of gfr estimated by the ckdepi and. Idmstraceable mdrd study equation conventional units gfr mlmin1. A more accurate method to estimate glomerular filtration rate. Ckdepi demonstrated superior performance compared with the existing mdrd equation but has not been applied to a healthcare system. The biggest limitation of this study is that there was no direct gold standard measurement of gfr eg, inulin or 125 iiothalamate clearance, yet recent reports of relationships between iothalamatederived gfr measures and cysc or egfr mdrd have been reported. Dec 15, 2009 levey and colleagues 1 presented a new equation for estimating glomerular filtration rate gfr, the chronic kidney disease epidemiology collaboration ckdepi, and compared the prevalence of chronic kidney disease ckd in the u. Gault equation and the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equation for drug dosing.
Glomerular filtration rate was estimated using the cockcroftgault, modification of diet in renal disease mdrd and chronic kidney disease epidemiology collaboration ckdepi equations, as well as cystatin cbased equations ckdepi cystatin c, cystatin c van deventer and ckdepi. Since serum creatinine is the variable with the greatest impact in gfr prediction equations, the need. The modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study consisted of two randomized. Ckdepi and the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equations for estimating gfr levels above 60 mlmin1. The prevalence of stage 3 ckd is significantly higher with the mdrd study equation p mdrd or ckdepi study equations. The prevalence of stage 3 ckd is significantly higher with the mdrd study equation p mdrd study equation was developed in whites and african americans, but performance was not evaluated in japanese. Creatinine clearance rate c cr or crcl is the volume of blood plasma that is cleared of creatinine per unit time and is a useful measure for approximating the gfr. Pdf prevalence of stage 3 chronic kidney disease ckd is increasing according to the nhanes study. Cystatin c and creatininebased equations in the assessment. Use of the mdrd study equation for drug dosing american.
Bias for the ckdepi was found to be lower than the fourvariable mdrd study equation, with a mean of. Renal function is an indication of the kidneys condition and its role in renal physiology glomerular filtration rate gfr describes the flow rate of filtered fluid through the kidney. In clinical practice, gfr is estimated from serum creatinine using the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equation or the cockcroftgault cg equation instead of the timeconsuming method of measured clearance for exogenous. The aim of the study was to measure the difference in prevalence of stage 3 ckd in a. Use of the mdrd study equation to estimate kidney function for drug dosing.
Gfr estimation using the cockcroftgault, mdrd study, and ckd. What is the mdrd formula for measuring kidney function in. Mdrd study 2006 same as above reexpressed for standardized assay mdrd study creatinine 2006 appropriate for use with standardized assays levey et al. Mdrd or ckdepi study equations for estimating prevalence. Diet in renal disease mdrd equation with and without ethnic. Oct 25, 20 the question for prevalence estimation and validation of the various egfrs in old age is still under debate. Although an equation developed in one population may be appropriate for use in that population, its use in other populations needs to be tested. The best validated method until recently came from the mdrd study data ann int med. Serum creatinine is measured more than 280 million times annually in the united states, and more than 80% of clinical laboratories now report an estimated glomerular filtration rate gfr when serum creatinine is measured. These downloadable pdf calculators were created as a rapid and convenient means to calculate and document estimates of glomerular filtration rate.
Mdrd study and ckdepi gfr estimating equations summary ta. Gault cg equation provides an estimate of creatinine clearance and is the equation most commonly used to determine drug dosages in patients with impaired kidney function. Pharmaceutical manufacturers have used the cockcroftgault equation to estimate kidney. Glomerular filtration rate was estimated using the cockcroftgault, modification of diet in renal disease mdrd and chronic kidney disease epidemiology collaboration ckdepi equations, as well as cystatin cbased equations ckdepi cystatin c, cystatin c van deventer and ckdepi combined compared to 51 credta plasma. Cystatin c identifies patients with stable chronic heart. Performance of glomerular filtration rate estimation. Gfr estimation by the mdrd equation using a standardized. The study population consisted of 100 treatmentnaive hiv patients. Modification of the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equation for japan.
The clinician and estimation of glomerular filtration rate. Correction for individual bsa improved the performances of the mdrd study and ckdepi equations in patients with body. The prevalence of stage 3 ckd in this population using the mdrd or the ckdepi equations was 11. Creatinine egfrcr mdrd study 1999 ckd 1628 1628, 0 nonstandardized mdrd study creatinine 1999 recommended by nkfkdoqi 2002 levey et al. Methods this crosssectional study compared the taiwanese egfr. Recently, the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd egfr equation. There are doubts about whether the values obtained from the cockroftgault cl cg and modification of diet in renal disease gfr mdrd formulas are comparable to the more traditional formula used to obtain the creatinine clearance from a 24hour urine collection clcr m, particularly in patients with only one kidney. Methods this crosssectional study compared the taiwanese egfr equations, the mdrd study, and the ckdepi.
Another formula was derived from data collected in the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study. The cockcroftgault cg, 4variable modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study, and ckd epidemiology collaboration ckdepi equations are the most widely used gfr estimates. In the validation data set, the idms mdrd study equation with the jsnckdi coefficient 0. Recently, a new estimator based on creatinine, the ckdepi equation, has been proposed which is presumed to better perform in normal gfr ranges. Estimated gfr vs creatinine clearance for drug dosing. Gfr prediction using the mdrd and cockcroft and gault. Ckdepi cystatin c 2012 ckdepi creatininecystatin c 2012 all ethnic groups other than african american shortcut. The prevalence of stage 3 to 5 chronic kidney disease ckd in japan 18. Relationship between nutritional status and the glomerular filtration rate. Accurate estimation of the glomerular filtration rate gfr is crucial for the detection of chronic kidney disease ckd.
Estimated glomerular filtration rate and albuminuria for. Abstract the objectives of this study were to compare the estimations of renal function obtained with six equations. In the development data set, egfr using the idms mdrd study equation overestimated mgfr throughout the entire range. Pdf modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study and. Epi equations in place of the cg equation was associated with dosage discrepancy in 2025% of patients and 15% of drug orders, resulting in potential. Relationship between nutritional status and the glomerular. Microsoft word mdrd study and ckdepi gfr estimating equations summary ta. Background the relationship between the proteinenergy nutritional status and renal function was assessed in 1785 clinically stable patients with moderate to advanced chronic renal failure who were evaluated during the baseline phase of the.
Background and objectives chronic kidney disease ckd is a significant public health problem whose diagnosis and staging relies upon gfrestimating equations, including the new ckdepi equation. However, the primary results published in 1994 were not conclusive with regard to the efficacy of this intervention. Alcohol use disorders identification testconcise auditc brief screen to detecting heavy alcohol use alcohol use disorders identification test audit screen for active alcohol abuse or dependence cage questionnaire 4 question screening for alcohol problems car, relax, alone, forget, friends, trouble crafft 2. One study revealed that the mean egfr bias of the simplified four variables original mdrd equation with beckman cx3 kinetic jaffe assay was reduced from 6. For members of the modification of diet in renal disease study group, see n engl j med. Design, setting, participants, and measurements a crosssectional study was conducted of patients who underwent renal function assessment for clinical purposes by simultaneous measurements of serum creatinine and estimation of gfr using the mdrd and ckdepi equations and renal clearance of iothalamate n 5238. This calculator uses the 4variable equation from levey 2006, as it has been recalibrated for differences in the lab testing of creatinine. The question for prevalence estimation and validation of the various egfrs in old age is still under debate. This equation should be used only with those creatinine methods that have been calibrated to be. More studies are necessary to verify the accuracy of the jsnckdi coefficient and jsnckdi equation in other settings in japan and elsewhere in asia. Standardization of serum creatinine and estimated gfr in. An opinion of the nephrology practice and research network of the american college of clinical pharmacy.
While measured glomerular filtration rate gfr remains the gold standard for assessing decreased kidney function, in routine clinical practice, gfr is usually estimated from serum creatinine by the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equation egfr mdrd. Cyscbased equations decreased the prevalence of reduced gfr by one third 9. This finding is somewhat different than our results, which demonstrate a bias of 1% in kidney transplant recipients using the mdrd equation and a bias of. Relative performance of the mdrd and ckdepi equations for. Indeed, in the levey study, if for subjects with gfr over 60 mlmin1. Estimation of glomerular filtration rate by the mdrd study. Our analysis suggests no effect of stable lithium maintenance therapy lithium levels in therapeutic range on the rate of change in egfr over time. Estimating glomerular filtration rate using the chronic. Method and results the renal function was similar with the chronic kidney disease epidemiology collaboration ckdepi median 59 mlmin1. Also, note that a later study indicates the mdrd may underestimate the actual gfr in healthy patients by up to 29%.
Dietary protein restriction and the progression of chronic. The cockcroftgault equation and the ckdepi equation corrected for individual body surface area bsa were associated with the highest p 30 69% and 67%, respectively and lowest rmse 39 and 36 mlmin, respectively in the 240 patients. Recent studies have shown that estimated gfr using serum cystatin c. Furthermore, we assessed prevalence of egfr in a populationbased sample of 85 year olds and investigated the performance of these egfrs in predicting.
Summary of the mdrd study and ckdepi estimating equations the table below summarizes gfr estimating equations developed by the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study. A simplified equation to predict glomerular filtration rate from serum creatinine abstract j am soc nephrol 2000 sep. The mdrd formula, also called the levey formula, is now widely accepted as more accurate. Gfr estimates using the idms mdrd study equation with the jsnckdi coefficient or the new jsnckdi equation are more accurate than the idms mdrd study equation in hospitalized japanese patients with egfr less than 60 mlmin1. Mdrd or ckdepi study equations for estimating prevalence of stage 3 ckd in epidemiological studies. Type underlined letters to toggle between variables. The ckdepi equation ref is more accurate at higher gfrs than the mdrd equation. For members of the modification of diet in renal disease study group, see. Gfr estimation using the cockcroftgault, mdrd study, and. The modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equation has also been proposed for this purpose. Several studies have compared drug dosing recommendations based on the cockcroftgault cg and the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equations, finding higher values for glomerular filtration rate estimated using the mdrd study equation and subsequently higher dosing recommendations. Prevalence has been calculated using the mdrd study equa tion for estimating glomerular filtration rate gfr. Epi equations and to evaluate the implication of using other equations for drug dosing in.
This prevalence was significantly and strongly higher than the prevalence obtained when the ckdepi study equation which was 7. Determining glomerular filtration rate gfr is necessary for diagnosing and classifying ckd and adjusting drug dosage. The ckdepi equation and mdrd study equation find similar. Calculate is a nextgeneration clinical calculator and decision support tool freely available to the medical community.
The chronic kidney disease epidemiology collaboration equation for estimation of glomerular filtration rate egfr ckdepi improves gfr estimation compared with the modification of diet in renal disease study equation egfr mdrd but its association with mortality in a nationally representative population sample in the us has not been studied. The beckman synchron cx3 assay also was calibrated to these creatinine reference standard methods, and the mdrd study equation was reexpressed for use with standardized values. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and figures for a period of 48 hours. Background it is unknown how the creatininebased renal function estimations differ for dose adjustment cutoffs and risk prediction in patients with heart failure. Modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study and ckd epidemiology collaboration ckdepi equations for taiwanese adults article pdf available in plos one 96. In the mdrd study population, 91% of gfr estimates were within 30% of the measured values and the equation explained 90. Comparison of the mdrd study and ckdepi equations for the. Implications of the ckdepi gfr estimation equation in. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view.
Stevens et al1 suggest that the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equation for estimated glomerular filtration rate gfr is an acceptable substitute for estimated or measured creatinine clearance ccr as an index for adjusting drug doses in patients with chronic kidney disease and acute kidney injury. Pdf modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study. Using the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd and. Modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study and ckd. As of january 20, many large commercial clinical laboratories have changed from using the mdrd study equation to the ckdepi creatine 2009 equation for egfr reporting. Creatininebased egfr and albuminuria should be taken into account for cardiovascular prediction, especially when these measures are already assessed for clinical purpose or if cardiovascular mortality and heart failure are outcomes of interest. Mdrd or ckdepi study equations for estimating prevalence of. However, others have raised concerns that injudicious use of estimated gfr. Comparison of risk prediction using the ckdepi equation and the mdrd study equation for estimated glomerular filtration rate. Age subgroup analysis showed that biases of the mdrd study and ckdepi equations did not vary significantly with age p 0.
The performances of the cockcroftgault, modification of. Comparison of risk prediction using the ckdepi equation. Background estimated glomerular filtration rate egfr using the modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study or the chronic kidney disease epidemiology collaboration ckdepi equations may not be accurate for asians. Our results therefore contradict the idea that longterm lithium therapy is associated with nephrotoxicity in the absence of episodes of acute intoxication and that duration of therapy and cumulative dose are the major. To assess renal function with increasing age, we estimated mean egfr, in subjects aged 2085 years. Furthermore, we assessed prevalence of egfr in a populationbased sample of 85 year olds and investigated the performance of these egfrs in predicting mortality in the oldest old. Published studies report that drug doses determined by the two equations do not agree. In the mdrd study population, the predicted crcl from the cockcroft and gault formula was adjusted to a standard body surface area but overestimated gfr by some 16%. May 01, 2012 serum creatinine is measured more than 280 million times annually in the united states, and more than 80% of clinical laboratories now report an estimated glomerular filtration rate gfr when serum creatinine is measured. Modification of diet in renal disease study group ann intern med 1999 mar 16. The equation developed from the mdrd study provided a more accurate estimate of gfr in our study group than measured creatinine clearance or other commonly used equations. Acr could have particularly broad implications for cardiovascular prediction.
The modification of diet in renal disease mdrd study equation was developed in whites and african. Comparing results of five glomerular filtration rate. Use of the mdrd study equation to estimate kidney function. Adding more variables albumin, urea adds little to accuracy. The objectives of this study were to compare the estimations of renal function obtained with six equations, including the cockcroftgault cg, modification of diet in renal disease mdrd, and chronic kidney disease epidemiology collaboration ckd. A more accurate method to estimate glomerular filtration. The abbreviated, or fourvariable equation includes age, sex, creatinine, and race black or not black. Logically, using the new ckdepi equations, the prevalence of stage 3 ckd in our population is significantly lower than if the mdrd study equation is used 7. Unlimited viewing of the articlechapter pdf and any associated. Pdf mdrd or ckdepi study equations for estimating prevalence. Comparing the association of gfr estimated by the ckdepi. Cystatin c identifies patients with stable chronic heart failure at increased risk for adverse cardiovascular events.
983 1576 319 90 938 833 470 498 171 813 1182 1143 1270 32 1131 814 1006 525 271 1372 365 458 998 461 773 1016 35 212 862 1159 1391 1311 1414 287 1385 961 995 133